In my opinion, this not a top-tier work of Dahl’s (Charlie and Matilda are my favorites of his, and I’m very found of Danny, the Champion of the World, although I didn’t read that one to the boys). But, as I realized when I started reading his books aloud, even his second-tier work sets a high bar. This book is odd and fun and surprising–how many authors would dare, have the hero’s parents, on the first page of the book, “suddenly . . . eaten up (in full daylight, mind you, and on a crowded street) by an enormous angry rhinoceros which had escaped the London Zoo”? Or have the hero’s companions be giant insects? (For obvious reasons, like other Dahl books, this would not be the best book for a particularly sensitive or anxious child. Things are truly terrible for James before they get much better. )
Like Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, I far prefer the original illustrations to those by Quentin Blake (who is now the default Dahl illustrator). Burkert’s pictures are very weird and atmospheric (James looks positively haunted, which makes perfect sense in the context of the book) and I love the subtle light peach color throughout the illustrations. I didn’t find its stop-motion movie very interesting and didn’t show it to the boys.
Author: Roald Dahl
Illustrator: Nancy Ekholm Burkert
